Women's Ordination: History, Issues & Implications

My Story and the Hermeneutical Question

Three Angels Broadcasting Network

Program transcript

Participants: C. Raymond Holmes

Home

Series Code: WOHII

Program Code: WOHII000017A


00:14 When I began my ministry in my last Lutheran Parish,
00:20 which by the way is only a little over a half mile
00:26 from the Adventist church I'm pastoring for the last 20 years
00:32 in retirement. Interesting situation. But when I began my
00:39 ministry there in the 60s it was not long before I discovered
00:46 that the congregation had been deeply influenced by the
00:51 prevailing social gospel of the times.
01:00 So I faced a challenge. How to counteract such influence
01:10 and get the congregation on a Biblical path?
01:18 I started by consistently preaching expository sermons
01:23 that focused on the Scriptures.
01:29 I preached longer sermons.
01:34 20 minutes was customary.
01:38 I extended it to thirty minutes.
01:43 Now I preach 45 minutes or longer
01:47 because I'm an old man, I have a lot to say
01:54 and a little time to say it!
02:02 Some folks didn't like the longer sermons.
02:09 But some did. I also tried to start a Sunday School class
02:17 for adults that would concentrate on Bible study
02:24 But I had few takers.
02:33 I remember also as a young minister being invited
02:43 to preach a series of sermons at a Bible camp.
02:49 That's what they called them in those days.
02:55 And after one of the evening meetings a lady came up to me
03:00 and asked me if she could talk with me. I said yes of course.
03:07 They were turning out the lights in the chapel so we had to sit
03:12 on the cement steps underneath one light bulb.
03:18 So we sat down and I asked her how can I help you? She said
03:22 Well I've been a believer for many years but I've got a
03:27 real serious problem she said. I don't have the assurance
03:31 of forgiveness of sins. I love God but I don't have the
03:35 assurance that He has forgiven my sin.
03:39 I thought Wow. They didn't teach me anything about how to
03:45 deal with that in the seminary.
03:48 So I shot a prayer up to God and He helped me.
03:56 I said well let's open our Bibles to 1 John 1:9
04:03 So she opened her Bible and I said, would you read that verse
04:09 out loud? And she did.
04:25 And I said to her, have you confessed your sins?
04:28 She said, Oh many, many times.
04:32 I said, are you forgiven?
04:36 She said, I don't know.
04:40 So I said, read it again.
04:44 So she read it out loud again.
04:54 I asked, have you confessed your sins?
04:59 She said, I just told you. Many times.
05:04 I said, are you forgiven? I don't know.
05:10 I said, read it again.
05:14 She looked at me you know, You've got to be kidding.
05:16 I said, come on read it again.
05:19 So she did and I asked her, have you confessed your sins? Yes.
05:26 I said, are you forgiven?
05:32 This time there was silence.
05:37 And I didn't interrupt her silence.
05:40 Finally she said, I guess I am!
05:47 And I said, how do you know that?
05:53 And she said, because it says so right here.
06:01 I learned a lot that day.
06:08 Well anyway, during this time starting the Sunday School class
06:13 for adults that failed and this experience with that lady
06:18 I've often wondered what happened to her.
06:22 Two other significant things happened. My wife was Vacation
06:28 Bible School leader that particular summer
06:33 and when the materials arrived that she had sent for
06:39 dealing with human origins she was alarmed.
06:46 And she came to me and showed the materials to me
06:50 and she said, we can't teach this.
06:55 It was teaching evolution, not Biblical creation.
07:01 I told her to send it back. And I wrote a letter
07:06 to the denominational publishers explaining why.
07:15 By that time she had become interested in the Adventist
07:19 church through a friend. She's staying with them now
07:24 in Berrien Springs while I am here.
07:29 And that same summer the Vacation Bible School material
07:33 was on creation and it was Biblical all the way through
07:43 The very first verse of the Bible says:
07:55 That's what it says and then it tells us how He did it.
08:03 By His Word. Amen. Amen.
08:10 Now, I'm going to insert a little footnote here.
08:14 All this was background to later events.
08:20 Eventually about some 20 years ago the ordination of women
08:26 ministers and in 2009 at their annual convention
08:37 that particular Lutheran denomination after a ten year
08:43 sociological study of human sexuality, not a Biblical study
08:50 a sociological study, they approved same sex marriage
08:56 and the ordination of gay clergy
09:02 How was that possible?
09:07 It was possible because the principles of interpretation
09:11 we call hermeneutics, were in place.
09:19 The progression from evolution to the approval of same
09:28 same sex marriage was inevitable.
09:34 Now somebody is going to say that my calling this to your
09:38 attention is scare tactics. But it's not. It's fact.
09:51 And the footnote. About the same time I attended a meeting
09:59 of Lutheran pastors during which the discussion
10:05 concerned hermeneutics. And I felt obliged to defend the
10:12 authority of the Bible. And one of the young pastors who was a
10:18 recent graduate of the same seminary that I had attended
10:24 came up to me and shook his finger in my face
10:28 and very angrily and vehemently said to me
10:33 Time is coming when people like you
10:37 will not be allowed in the ministry.
10:45 Now most of you who know some of my story probably know
10:51 the rest that happened after these events that I described.
10:58 That the Fall of 1970 brought me as a master of theology
11:02 student to the theological seminary at Andrews University
11:07 I was still a Lutheran, still a skeptical.
11:13 And my primary goal at that time was to discover whether Jesus
11:19 lived on the campus of Andrews University,
11:25 and in the lives of the students and faculty.
11:30 And I discovered that He did.
11:39 I eventually decided to leave the Lutheran church
11:44 ministry and become a Seventh Day Adventist.
11:47 Nobody made any promises to me I didn't know what was
11:51 going to happen. I eventually ended up as a member of the
11:57 faculty myself, the pinnacle of my ministry.
12:04 It was wonderful, those years.
12:12 I remember a number of the faculty members invited me to
12:18 meet with them every Wednesday evening.
12:22 The only condition was that I tell them a week in advance
12:26 what I would like to discuss so they could prepare.
12:32 WGC Murdoch was there who was the Dean.
12:35 Dr. Tom Blinkos, chair of the Theology Department
12:40 Dr. Wilbur Alexander, Dr. C. Mervyn Maxwell
12:49 a couple others I can't remember It was masterfully done.
12:58 By the way everybody treated me with respect.
13:02 Everybody called me Pastor Holmes.
13:06 Nobody intimated that I was an apostate.
13:15 I felt accepted, even appreciated.
13:22 We studied. It was masterfully done. With one question in mind
13:28 What does the Bible say?
13:43 Now against that kind of a background you might imagine how
13:48 impressed I was with the SDA Sabbath School lessons
13:58 Remember I couldn't get an adult Sunday School class
14:01 started to study the Bible. And here I found a church
14:06 in which a large percentage of its membership attended
14:13 an hour's Sabbath School class before the worship service.
14:21 And now I thought, boy these people are something.
14:23 They're in church all morning on Saturday!
14:29 I wasn't used to that. And those lessons exposed Biblical truth
14:37 in depth and applied it. And how impressed I also was
14:45 with the prevailing expository approach to preaching
14:49 that I heard in those days.
14:53 All emphases that was part of my spiritual heritage
14:59 because my spiritual roots are in the Finnish Lutheran church
15:06 of Finland which was characterized by a strong
15:13 Biblicism on the one hand and a major emphasis on revival and
15:19 and awakening on the other.
15:26 So, right from the start of my spiritual life as I began to
15:31 read and study the Bible, I was deeply impressed by
15:35 the Apostle Paul's reverence for and reliance upon Scripture
15:46 And later as I dug deeper into the Protestant Reformation
15:49 I was so impressed by the impact that Paul had made on Luther
15:56 who is still one of my heroes. I was so impressed with the
16:04 chapter on the Reformation and Luther in Ellen White's book
16:07 The Great Controversy. You remember that Luther
16:15 at the Diet of Worms stood before the representatives
16:19 of both secular and religious power and authority
16:23 and under extreme pressure and even threat to his life
16:30 threat to renounce the convictions he had declared
16:35 in his 95 theses in 1517, almost 500 years in 2 years from now.
16:46 And he defied the holy Roman Emperor and the representatives
16:54 of the Pope. Can you imagine? Picture that, at this huge
17:00 gathering, here's this one simple monk
17:08 dressed in his monk's habit and he defied them both
17:15 by saying this. They asked him to recant, not asked him
17:24 but threatened him, you have to. And he said:
18:35 Now that kind of confident and fearless witness to scripture
18:42 is my spiritual heritage and nobody told me that I had to
18:50 abandon that heritage in order to become Seventh Day Adventist
18:56 It's still there and I believe that it fortifies me
19:07 for today. That's my spiritual heritage and I was convinced
19:16 that it was that also of the Seventh Day Adventist church
19:24 and I want to say to you folks that if we lose that
19:27 we lose everything. I was so impressed with the Bible
19:36 Conferences that were held throughout North America
19:40 in 1974. I was baptized in January of '71
19:46 by Dr. Tom Blinko at Pioneer Memorial Church and shortly
19:53 after ordained into the Adventist ministry.
19:56 But I was so impressed with those Bible conferences
20:01 in 1974 and also with Ellen White's hermeneutics
20:10 or principles of interpretation that one doesn't have to be
20:16 a trained scholar to understand and apply them.
20:22 And by the way when I studied Adventist Church history
20:26 you know when we talk about the group that was called Pioneers
20:32 just a handful of people from different churches meeting
20:35 together to study the Bible, that were influential in
20:40 in founding this church, this movement, not one of them
20:46 not one single one of that group had a PhD.
20:52 Not one of them was a scholar trained in Biblical languages
20:58 Their method was simple, two fold. Study the Bible
21:01 and pray. Discuss, yes. Their discussions were lively.
21:07 But they hammered out the doctrines on the basis of
21:12 the Word of God that initiated this movement.
21:22 Ellen White's principles are simple.
21:27 No.1, the Bible is its own interpreter.
21:32 No.2, take the Bible as it reads.
21:37 No.3, Focus on the Bible's plain statements.
21:41 No.4, explain the language of the Bible
21:48 according to its obvious meaning.
21:59 You can use those principles and arrive at confident
22:06 conclusions about God's truth.
22:12 I found a spiritual home and I joined the Seventh Day Adventist
22:19 church and its ministry, confident that it was in
22:24 submission to the full authority of the Bible.
22:36 And then this issue emerged.
22:44 And I resisted two years getting involved in it.
22:50 Because I didn't want to be crucified on that cross.
22:57 My wife warned me over and over again.
23:01 She said don't get involved you're going to get in trouble.
23:08 But the more I saw the way the Bible was being used or rather
23:12 misused in trying to convince the church that the Bible
23:19 doesn't say what it says, the more I came under the impression
23:26 that I had to do what I did and write the book
23:34 The Tip of An Iceberg. It's the 20th anniversary
23:39 of the publication of that book in May of this year.
23:48 It's a form of deception folks to try and convince the church
23:54 that the Bible doesn't say what it says.
24:01 And any Reformation scholar knows that Luther was heavily
24:06 influenced by the epistles of Paul. That he drew theological
24:12 doctrinal knowledge from Paul's letters as well as
24:16 personal faith and the kind of courage and spiritual strength
24:21 that he needed at the time of crisis.
24:27 The words of Paul changed Luther.
24:32 And through him the course of history and the world.
24:39 You and I would not be here today in this sanctuary
24:45 preaching, teaching, studying, believing the Gospel
24:49 of salvation by grace through faith were it not for the words
24:55 of Paul. Words that were heard by a simple monk
25:05 who was sincerely trying to do everything that he thought
25:10 was necessary to be accepted by God.
25:16 But his efforts didn't satisfy including self flagellation.
25:27 Until he heard from Romans 3:24 that he was justified
25:36 by God's grace as a gift through the redemption
25:41 that is in Christ Jesus.
25:47 But before he could hear that he had to hear something else.
25:52 He called it Sola Scriptura.
25:57 The Bible and the Bible alone as the source of God's
26:03 revelation and of truth.
26:12 But before Sola Scriptura comes something else.
26:18 Before Sola Gracia, grace alone and Sola Fide, faith alone
26:25 comes Sola Scriptura, the Bible alone.
26:33 That was the major fundamental truth of the Reformation.
26:40 Sola Scriptura. Everything. Doctrinal and experiential
26:48 depends on and derives from Sola Scriptura.
26:57 But you know the medieval church never accepted that.
27:06 Insisting that tradition and the power of bishops
27:11 read administrators, theologians are equal if not pre-eminent
27:19 to Scripture. In other words the authority of the church
27:27 was above that of the Word of God.
27:34 Some protestants today give lip service to Sola Scriptura
27:40 and in some instances abandoning it altogether in favor of
27:49 what is called "felt human needs"
27:57 and the pressures and demands of contemporary culture.
28:03 Now here's another footnote.
28:09 This has culminated in a recent joint Lutheran Catholic
28:15 declaration, notice I said joint Lutheran Catholic declaration
28:22 that the Reformation was a mistake.
28:29 That the protest is over.
28:36 Of course it would be over to many.
28:46 It's inevitable. If you throw out Sola Scriptura
28:54 you throw out the Reformation
29:02 and the footnote. Disconnecting the Old from the New Testament
29:09 Law from Gospel. In some instances insisting
29:16 that the Holy Spirit is doing new things in the Church
29:20 in our time. Have you heard that recently?
29:30 Put the authority of the Spirit above that of the Word.
29:37 But Ellen White says that the Holy Spirit never leads us
29:44 in a way that's contradictory to the Scriptures.
29:55 Attention needs to be drawn once again to Paul's reverence
30:00 for and reliance upon the Scriptures.
30:07 He begins Romans by calling attention in the 1st chapter
30:12 verse 2 to the Scriptures. To the Holy Scriptures.
30:18 And when he deals with justification in chapter 4
30:21 verse 3, he asks what does the Scripture say?
30:29 And he answers, Abraham believed God and it was counted to him
30:33 as righteousness. And then in chapter 9 of Romans, verse 6
30:41 he calls Scripture "the Word of God".
30:48 And in making clear there is no distinction between Jew and
30:53 Greek with regard to salvation he says in chapter 10 verse 11
30:58 the Scripture says. Everyone who believes in him, Jesus,
31:05 will not be put to shame.
31:09 And in chapter 11 verse 2 he underscores that "God has not
31:16 rejected His people" the Jews and then he asks,
31:22 do you know what the Scripture says?
31:33 According to Paul it's in the Scripture, in the Bible
31:36 that we find hope. Chapter 15 verse 4.
31:56 And when it came to the authority that he claimed
32:00 for the preaching of the gospel for the death and resurrection
32:03 of Christ, Paul said unequivocally
32:07 in 1 Corinthians 15, verses 3 and 4, he said that it was
32:15 "In accordance with the Scriptures"
32:22 And speaking further of hope in context of his own ministry
32:26 Paul says, 2 Corinthians 4 verses 13-18, he says
33:47 Throughout Romans and 1 and 2 Corinthians,
33:51 and Lutherans love those three books, at least they used to
33:56 Paul uses the phrase "it is written' over and over again.
34:03 At least 13 times. Then he says in 2 Corinthians 6
34:49 Then he says, Paul says:
35:06 Now whether Paul talks about his development of the truth
35:14 doctrine, by the way that's what doctrine means, truth
35:23 whether he's talking about that or if he's talking about
35:27 the development of his own theological thought, or
35:31 whether he's addressing issues in the developing early church
35:35 his reference is always the Scripture.
35:44 Now contrast that with trying to convince the church that
35:50 the Bible doesn't really say what it says.
36:00 No wonder that deeply involved in the development and
36:04 organizing of the early church he underscored for both Timothy
36:10 and Titus, as he says to Timothy "as for you", when I read that
36:21 it's very personal, he's saying that to me.
37:21 We need to be aware of the fact that Paul's letters bear witness
37:32 that he was as conscious of the leading of the Holy Spirit
37:38 as he was of the power and influence of the Scriptures
37:43 However, and here is a vital principle of interpretation
38:02 It's on the basis of Scripture alone that both qualification
38:10 for ministry and how the Spirit empowered equipping for ministry
38:16 is revealed and accomplished and what an example Paul was!
39:23 So it was in complete harmony with his faith in and reliance
39:30 upon the written word of God to leave as his legacy
39:36 of apostolic instruction.
39:39 These resounding words that we are careful to read
39:46 at ordination services from 2 Timothy 4 verses 1-5
39:55 Anyway here are the words from 2 Timothy 4
41:16 How does the preacher rebuke?
41:20 By throwing his weight around? By exercising authority?
41:30 No! By preaching the Word.
41:46 The power is in the Word, not in the preacher.
41:55 Preach the Word. But do it he says in patience.
42:01 And in love. Preach the Word. Nothing else.
42:06 That's our duty. That's our calling. That's our ministry.
42:12 That's our mission, no matter what. Popular or not.
42:22 And do it consistently. Without deviation, without compromise
42:27 of Biblical principles for the sake of peace.
42:33 Why? Ellen White has the answer.
42:40 From the Review and Herald, July 24, 1894.
43:06 Do we have to often proclaim a message that's in opposition
43:11 to sins, prejudices and so on?
43:18 Why in the context of this solemn charge does Paul say
43:24 to the ordinand as for you endure suffering.
43:36 Why does he say that?
43:42 Because friends there's a price to pay
43:48 for faithfulness to God's Word.
43:53 To His will, to His truth.
44:01 Because Ellen White says in the same article
44:52 Folks, compromising the Word of God
44:55 is not the way to finish the work.
45:08 Now, did Paul himself pay that price?
45:13 Suffering? enduring suffering?
45:18 Let him tell the story himself in 2 Corinthians 11, verse 24
45:53 He lost friends. You know, as precious as it is
46:03 there are some things that are more important than friendship
47:03 Wow! There's a price to pay.
47:11 And as we look at the mission of our church
47:15 and the times in which we live let us trust that,
47:22 as Ellen White puts it in Great Controversy page 595
47:54 And also what she say in Selected Messages, Vol 2, pg.380
48:31 The Church will remain true to the Word of God
48:35 But that will not happen, notice, without the word
48:43 of their testimony. We have to stand up and be counted
48:55 When the issue is truth there is no such thing as anonymity
49:03 Remember Luther, "Here I stand"
49:08 I can't do anything else.
49:19 Then she goes on and she says that it's the very struggle
49:26 for Biblical truth that makes the church strong.
49:50 You know what my wife said when all of this agony began to take
49:56 place? She said, you know I think it's God's will
50:04 that the Remnant Church go through this agony.
50:11 And I said, why do you think that?
50:14 She said, because I think it's part of God's answer to our
50:19 prayers for revival and reformation.
50:26 Now we're hearing many appeals to unity today
50:32 and we all know that unity is essential to finish the mission
50:37 we have been given. And I want to borrow a metaphor
50:43 some of you will recognize the source of it
50:47 and say yes, we must sing in harmony, that is in agreement
50:54 in thought and action. But in order to sing in harmony
50:59 this choir knows what I'm talking about.
51:02 In order to sing in harmony, we have to sing in unison.
51:10 Which means to sing the same song.
51:15 With the same song and the same pitch with our eyes fixed
51:21 on the Director, spelled with a capital D. And the score
51:27 as written by the composer.
51:32 No choir can sing in harmony or in unison apart from unity
51:42 If each member or segment such as the tenors or sopranos
51:46 does not sing the same music, what happens?
51:52 Only discord and disharmony and you'd put your hands
51:56 over your ears. Finally,
52:27 A steward is one who takes care of, who cares for
52:34 one who protects. One who can be depended upon
52:41 to stay true to the Word of God.
53:33 As stewards of the mysteries of God it's our duty
53:39 to affirm and sustain the Biblical trajectories,
53:44 and I'm borrowing a word there of male headship and leadership
53:48 in the home and in the church and not go beyond what's written
53:54 in the Scriptures. Leadership that began before the fall
54:00 continued through the Old Testament Priesthood and
54:04 New Testament apostles and into the early church
54:07 through the Holy Spirit inspired instructions of Paul to Timothy
54:12 and Titus. As stewards of the mystery of God it is our duty
54:20 to pay careful attention to Paul's counsel to Timothy
54:24 in 1 Timothy 6:20 "Guard the deposit"
54:32 This is to say the revealed Word, the doctrine, the truth
54:36 that has been entrusted to us. Are we going to be trustworthy?
54:43 And do that? And guard that truth?
54:47 No matter what price it costs?
54:53 And concerning the truth itself, listen to this.
55:13 It doesn't take a lot of words and involved explanation
55:21 to do it. Now concerning hermeneutics, the interpretation
55:29 or the understanding and the application of the truth
55:33 she exhorts all of us. Members, pastors, leaders, evangelists
55:37 scholars, teachers in Selected Messages
56:16 Here is the motivation for this symposium.
56:22 I'm so glad I've been able to participate at age 85.
56:34 I'm so glad Pr. Bohr, you took the bit in your teeth and did it
56:47 Is there going to be a fallout? Oh yes, it's already started.
56:55 On the blogs. My final comment. It is our duty and that's why
57:08 we're here, as stewards of the mysteries of God to protect
57:15 the church from a hermeneutical disaster.
57:24 That's the bottom line. Amen.


Home

Revised 2016-01-19