Welcome to the Liberty Insider. 00:00:25.82\00:00:27.39 This is your program bringing you up-to-date news, views, 00:00:27.42\00:00:30.89 discussion, and insights on religious liberty events 00:00:30.93\00:00:34.06 in the U.S. certainly, but around the world. 00:00:34.43\00:00:36.53 My name is Lincoln Steed, editor of Liberty Magazine. 00:00:36.87\00:00:39.90 And my guest on this program is Ed Cook, Dr. Ed Cook, 00:00:40.07\00:00:43.77 author, sometimes for Liberty Magazine, 00:00:44.71\00:00:47.11 minister of religion, but your doctorate is in 00:00:47.54\00:00:49.94 church-state studies. 00:00:49.98\00:00:51.31 So you're on the right program here, because that's our thing. 00:00:51.35\00:00:57.32 In a previous program we had spoken about 00:00:57.35\00:01:01.29 the Jesuit Order within Roman Catholicism 00:01:02.12\00:01:04.43 and its origins and connection to the, 00:01:04.46\00:01:06.59 not so much to the Reformation, but to the Counter-Reformation. 00:01:06.90\00:01:09.66 But I think while there are one billion Roman Catholics, right, 00:01:11.23\00:01:15.37 in the world today, give or take... 00:01:15.64\00:01:17.47 Although, a bit like Islam, you're born a Roman Catholic. 00:01:17.81\00:01:22.84 You may not go to confession or anything... 00:01:22.88\00:01:25.25 In fact, they don't have confession in the old sense 00:01:25.95\00:01:27.98 in most places. 00:01:28.02\00:01:29.35 You may not go to mass very often, 00:01:29.38\00:01:31.35 but you are a Catholic, born a Catholic. 00:01:31.39\00:01:33.19 So I'm not sure that one billion, when you really 00:01:33.22\00:01:37.99 get down to the nub, how many are actively involved. 00:01:38.56\00:01:41.83 But there's an adherence normally of a billion. 00:01:41.86\00:01:45.33 They would know who Jesuits are, right? 00:01:46.10\00:01:48.54 ~ Sure. 00:01:48.57\00:01:49.90 But I think in recent years with the explosion of global news 00:01:49.94\00:01:52.84 and so on, and the telegenic Pope Francis, 00:01:52.87\00:01:57.08 a Jesuit, I think the people sort of pricked up their ears, 00:01:57.71\00:02:00.92 "Who are the Jesuits?" 00:02:00.95\00:02:02.28 ~ Well actually, there were a number of articles 00:02:02.32\00:02:03.89 that came out; one by Huffington Post, 00:02:03.92\00:02:05.72 another by The Daily Beast, another one by TIME, 00:02:05.75\00:02:08.99 that dealt with that specific issue that he was the first 00:02:09.19\00:02:12.09 Jesuit to be elected as the pope. 00:02:12.13\00:02:13.90 And that's got to be significant, 00:02:13.93\00:02:15.26 because Jesuits were the foot soldiers of the papacy. 00:02:15.30\00:02:18.73 But at different times they've even been 00:02:19.43\00:02:20.90 looked upon with suspicion. 00:02:20.94\00:02:22.30 ~ And even banned at one point. - Right. 00:02:23.07\00:02:24.97 And in the 70's, Pope John Paul II had a big run in 00:02:25.01\00:02:28.24 with them and was ready to dissolve the Order. 00:02:28.28\00:02:32.45 But they've been brought to heal, and I think with 00:02:32.65\00:02:35.25 a Jesuit pope I think their influence is very high. 00:02:35.88\00:02:39.69 It must be. 00:02:39.72\00:02:41.06 Now you and I are Seventh-day Adventists. 00:02:41.92\00:02:43.56 In our Adventist community there are some people that 00:02:43.76\00:02:47.33 are buzzing around with all sorts of conspiracies 00:02:47.36\00:02:49.56 and all the rest, and I'm constantly coming across 00:02:49.60\00:02:52.33 people claiming that Islam was begun by the Jesuits. 00:02:52.37\00:02:55.77 And what else would they say? 00:02:56.40\00:03:01.64 Oh, that the Illuminati and the whole Masonic Order 00:03:01.68\00:03:06.48 was begun by the Jesuits. 00:03:06.51\00:03:07.98 Could this be true? 00:03:08.38\00:03:09.95 From what you know of history. 00:03:10.72\00:03:12.05 From what, you know, everything, all of the historical documents 00:03:12.09\00:03:15.26 by the Jesuit Order itself and the Catholic Church, 00:03:15.89\00:03:18.66 as well as other non-Catholics that are historians that have, 00:03:18.69\00:03:22.56 and from a broad perspective of educational backgrounds, 00:03:22.60\00:03:25.67 I would say the definitive answer is, no. 00:03:25.87\00:03:28.07 ~ Right, I wanted you to say it. 00:03:28.10\00:03:29.44 Jesuits have not started any of these. 00:03:29.47\00:03:31.41 And if I had a Muslim Imam, he'd be babbling 00:03:31.44\00:03:34.44 in horror at the idea. 00:03:34.84\00:03:36.91 There's no historical evidence. 00:03:36.95\00:03:38.35 In fact, there isn't any evidence. 00:03:38.38\00:03:40.18 There's evidence to the contrary. 00:03:40.22\00:03:41.55 ~ Correct. 00:03:41.58\00:03:42.92 But perhaps it says something for the perceived power 00:03:42.95\00:03:45.89 and influence of the Jesuit Order through the ages 00:03:45.92\00:03:48.26 that this claim can even be made. 00:03:48.52\00:03:50.26 ~ In fact, one thing, just commenting on that 00:03:50.56\00:03:52.49 I would mention from a historical perspective. 00:03:52.53\00:03:54.63 You know, the Jesuits, as we mentioned in a previous segment, 00:03:55.10\00:03:57.60 they started in 1534, were officially recognized in 1540, 00:03:58.07\00:04:02.74 and had grown up to a thousand members by 1556. 00:04:02.77\00:04:05.84 By 1615, they had reached 13,000 male priests 00:04:05.87\00:04:10.58 that were part of the Order. 00:04:10.61\00:04:11.95 Now one of the things that, during that period of the 00:04:11.98\00:04:14.88 17th century from roughly 1600 to 1685 or 1690, they were 00:04:14.92\00:04:21.42 very instrumental in the Catholic Counter-Reformation. 00:04:21.46\00:04:25.09 And many of the countries that had become Protestant, 00:04:25.19\00:04:27.66 formerly Catholic that had become Protestant, 00:04:27.70\00:04:29.76 now they converted back again to Catholicism. 00:04:29.86\00:04:32.40 But the thing I was going to mention about that 00:04:32.83\00:04:34.37 is that the term, "Jesuit," is something that 00:04:34.40\00:04:37.71 in the hearts of Protestants during that era, it did strike 00:04:37.74\00:04:41.31 a note of fear because they recognized that 00:04:41.34\00:04:44.05 Jesuits were a part of the extension of the church, 00:04:44.08\00:04:46.88 part of the inquisitorial process, 00:04:47.28\00:04:49.18 and also very learned and astute men. 00:04:49.22\00:04:52.79 And also, I don't have a copy of it here, but there... 00:04:52.82\00:04:58.73 How can I characterize it? 00:05:00.00\00:05:01.33 Basically what they swore to, you know, their... 00:05:01.36\00:05:04.10 ~ Oath of allegiance. - Oath of allegiance. 00:05:04.40\00:05:06.33 It's rather blood curdling, and it's taking what Paul said 00:05:06.53\00:05:10.24 and enlarging it in ways that I don't think 00:05:10.27\00:05:12.64 most Christians would imagine. 00:05:12.67\00:05:14.01 You know Paul says, "I determine to be all things to all people." 00:05:14.04\00:05:16.34 I don't think Paul meant anything beyond not 00:05:17.48\00:05:20.22 challenging people, but suiting Christ to the occasions 00:05:20.85\00:05:25.05 and capitalizing on everything. 00:05:25.09\00:05:26.52 But you know, the Jesuits at different times have masqueraded 00:05:26.55\00:05:30.43 as other...to get into other belief systems 00:05:30.46\00:05:33.96 and get them from the inside out. 00:05:34.00\00:05:36.67 And I think that's perhaps why it's plausible to certain people 00:05:38.03\00:05:42.17 that they might have begun Islam, that they might have 00:05:42.20\00:05:45.14 been within the Knights Templar Orders, or whatever. 00:05:45.71\00:05:51.61 It's part of the fact, the history, that the 00:05:52.58\00:05:54.48 Roman Catholic Church has persecuted Masonry. 00:05:54.52\00:05:58.05 It has seen it correctly as a competitor. 00:05:58.35\00:06:02.56 So the idea that the Jesuits would have 00:06:02.72\00:06:04.16 started it is just nonsense to me. 00:06:04.19\00:06:05.96 In the late 1700's it was Pope Leo that actually wrote 00:06:05.99\00:06:09.56 several dogmatic statements, declarations of the church, 00:06:09.83\00:06:14.30 denouncing any kind of secret societies, 00:06:14.37\00:06:16.94 as they were referred to back then. 00:06:16.97\00:06:18.51 But I know on one occasion at least, a Jesuit 00:06:18.54\00:06:21.71 made huge inroads into Protestant thinking, 00:06:22.14\00:06:24.95 and something that we're bearing with in the U.S. now. 00:06:24.98\00:06:27.62 Does the name Ribera mean anything to you? 00:06:28.18\00:06:30.45 ~ Yes. - Tell me. 00:06:30.49\00:06:32.52 Well, you know, he's an individual that 00:06:32.62\00:06:35.76 had been a Catholic Priest and ended up converting out 00:06:36.52\00:06:41.96 and wrote quite a lot about the Order itself 00:06:42.00\00:06:45.07 and the inroads that the Catholic Church, 00:06:45.10\00:06:48.14 through the Society of Jesus, has attempted to do in trying to 00:06:48.17\00:06:51.24 penetrate Protestantism. 00:06:51.27\00:06:52.87 Well no, I think you're thinking of another name. 00:06:53.31\00:06:56.31 But it was a Jesuit priest, I'm trying to remember 00:06:56.41\00:06:58.78 his first name, Ribera, that came up with a method of 00:06:58.81\00:07:04.42 interpreting apocalyptic prophecies. 00:07:04.45\00:07:06.76 That conveniently re-wrote things to the extent so that 00:07:07.46\00:07:13.80 as the Protestants under Martin Luther were identifying 00:07:13.83\00:07:16.30 Rome as antichrist and so on, that all of that disappeared. 00:07:16.33\00:07:19.57 Because you're looking back, 00:07:19.60\00:07:20.94 and it's dispensationalism, and so on. 00:07:21.97\00:07:24.17 And there's no question that a Jesuit attempt to denature 00:07:24.21\00:07:29.11 the apocalyptic aspects of Protestantism 00:07:29.14\00:07:32.61 has led directly to what we have in the United States today 00:07:32.71\00:07:36.28 where evangelical Christianity... 00:07:36.32\00:07:38.09 ~ Dispensationalism. - Yeah. 00:07:38.12\00:07:39.49 ...are looking for something quite literal to take place 00:07:39.52\00:07:42.99 in the Middle East rather than perhaps spiritual developments 00:07:43.02\00:07:48.66 within, as Ellen White an Adventist writer 00:07:48.70\00:07:51.97 use to say, Christendom. 00:07:52.00\00:07:53.34 There's actually two positions that those priests, 00:07:53.50\00:07:57.11 those Jesuit priests, had developed regarding prophecy. 00:07:57.14\00:07:59.87 One is almost a purely futuristic perspective 00:08:00.08\00:08:03.58 where they move all of the prophecies to future events. 00:08:03.61\00:08:07.18 And then the other one is dealing with, 00:08:07.28\00:08:08.68 it's all relegated to the past. 00:08:08.72\00:08:10.59 It's happened in past history. 00:08:10.62\00:08:12.59 ~ Problematic principle, as they would say. 00:08:12.62\00:08:14.36 So yeah, but the whole point of it was diversion. 00:08:14.39\00:08:17.43 To take away from... 00:08:17.53\00:08:18.86 You know, people have forgotten Martin Luther, 00:08:18.99\00:08:21.00 I think, to a large degree. 00:08:21.26\00:08:22.70 They think that it was all justification by faith, 00:08:23.16\00:08:26.97 and Rome sort of squashed him because of that. 00:08:27.00\00:08:29.97 I read, re-read, the 95 Theses the other day. 00:08:30.01\00:08:32.87 And it was quite illuminating. 00:08:33.58\00:08:34.91 I'd read them years ago, but I hadn't looked at them 00:08:34.94\00:08:37.38 sort of this dispassionately. 00:08:37.41\00:08:39.28 And they're not really 95 discrete points. 00:08:39.71\00:08:42.78 They're 95 variations on a theme. 00:08:42.82\00:08:44.69 And the theme is the pope and the church, 00:08:44.72\00:08:48.02 medieval church that he represented, 00:08:48.22\00:08:50.26 Martin Luther felt had no authority and had usurped 00:08:50.66\00:08:54.56 any limited authority and carried forward 00:08:54.60\00:08:57.70 its edicts and doctrines, and so on. 00:08:57.90\00:08:59.53 So it was all a matter of authority. 00:08:59.57\00:09:01.57 Dealing with papal primacy, in essence that's the 00:09:02.07\00:09:05.97 term that Catholics would use in recognition of 00:09:06.01\00:09:09.04 the role of what they call the primacy of Peter, 00:09:09.08\00:09:14.52 from Peter down to whatever current pope is ruling. 00:09:14.55\00:09:17.25 And so in line with that, he saw biblical prophecies... 00:09:17.29\00:09:21.39 ...you know, they're in code, but they suggest that a 00:09:23.89\00:09:27.10 religious power at the end of time will seek to change 00:09:27.13\00:09:30.03 times and seasons, and speak haughtily, and so on. 00:09:30.07\00:09:34.14 ~ You know, something that I think is interesting 00:09:34.17\00:09:35.80 and a very important point is that, you're correct in stating, 00:09:35.84\00:09:39.04 that Luther in his study of Scripture reached a point, 00:09:39.07\00:09:42.61 after the Protestant Reformation had begun in 1517, 00:09:42.81\00:09:45.81 he reached a point in his study of Scripture 00:09:46.15\00:09:48.05 where he identified the pope as the, in essence, 00:09:48.08\00:09:52.19 this beast power; in essence referring to 00:09:52.22\00:09:55.12 the pope as the antichrist. 00:09:55.16\00:09:56.73 But the idea of the papal institution being the antichrist 00:09:56.93\00:10:01.16 was not actually original to Luther. 00:10:01.20\00:10:03.47 ~ No, no. Certainly not. 00:10:03.50\00:10:05.00 Because since the 1300's there were some of the other 00:10:05.03\00:10:07.24 Orders within the Catholic Church, the Franciscans, 00:10:07.27\00:10:09.97 had questioned that and they actually applied the term, 00:10:10.01\00:10:12.87 the antichrist, to the papal positions. 00:10:12.97\00:10:16.04 ~ Absolutely. Oh no. 00:10:16.08\00:10:17.41 - No, but I simply mention that because from a Catholic 00:10:17.45\00:10:19.68 perspective, that's within Catholicism. 00:10:19.71\00:10:21.58 - King Solomon says there's nothing new under the sun. 00:10:21.62\00:10:23.28 But Martin Luther made it almost to a fault the feature of his 00:10:23.72\00:10:29.96 resistance in some of the cartoons and even 00:10:31.03\00:10:34.46 pamphlets he wrote to make you cringe today. 00:10:34.50\00:10:37.03 Not so much that they were theologically wrong, but 00:10:37.60\00:10:39.93 they are very ill advised graphics, in my view. 00:10:39.97\00:10:44.67 But that was very much what Luther was about. 00:10:44.77\00:10:47.74 And so the Jesuits, I think, were doing a very necessary job, 00:10:48.14\00:10:52.78 and they did it very well, to turn this apocalyptic 00:10:52.81\00:10:56.05 interest in the Bible in two directions away. 00:10:56.15\00:10:59.35 ~ Correct. 00:10:59.85\00:11:01.19 And they've been very successful. 00:11:01.22\00:11:02.56 And as you mentioned, those viewpoints 00:11:02.92\00:11:05.56 have led in later centuries to the development of a 00:11:05.76\00:11:08.23 particular line of theological interpretation 00:11:08.26\00:11:11.47 of prophesy, part of that being the aspect of dispensationalism. 00:11:11.67\00:11:15.97 So where do you think the Jesuit Order is heading today? 00:11:16.64\00:11:20.51 From your analysis. 00:11:20.88\00:11:22.21 Because you're... I mean, I read a lot of it. 00:11:22.24\00:11:23.95 But I imagine you read even more of the internal documents 00:11:23.98\00:11:26.55 of the Roman Catholic Church. 00:11:26.58\00:11:28.05 Well for the Jesuits of today, they recognize that even though 00:11:28.35\00:11:33.56 part of their, I would say their primary focus 00:11:33.59\00:11:36.29 is on educational effort. 00:11:36.32\00:11:37.93 You know, that's always been an earmark of their Order. 00:11:37.96\00:11:40.56 And they've been very successful at it. 00:11:40.86\00:11:42.50 You know, just for example, a couple of institutions... 00:11:42.53\00:11:45.03 ~ And it's not a bad thing. 00:11:45.07\00:11:46.40 I mean, when Jesuitism began, educational levels 00:11:46.43\00:11:53.68 were not very high in Europe. 00:11:53.71\00:11:55.04 And in a way, they had the beast by the tail, 00:11:55.64\00:12:00.98 because increased education created agitation against 00:12:01.18\00:12:05.12 the control of Rome. 00:12:05.15\00:12:06.76 It was really education that directly led to the Reformation. 00:12:06.79\00:12:09.69 So you could have thought that they would just be against 00:12:11.13\00:12:14.76 education and control it all. 00:12:14.80\00:12:16.36 But they respected knowledge. 00:12:16.40\00:12:18.47 But they wanted to direct it to the ends of the papacy. 00:12:18.57\00:12:21.37 - There's no question. ~ Correct. 00:12:21.40\00:12:22.74 One could say that, in essence, rather than entering into 00:12:22.77\00:12:26.34 conflict with the educational efforts, they actually 00:12:26.37\00:12:30.08 utilized it to achieve the ends that they had in mind. 00:12:30.11\00:12:33.35 So coming back to mention that here in America, 00:12:33.82\00:12:37.12 just for example, there's Fordham University in New York, 00:12:37.15\00:12:39.69 there's Georgetown University in the D.C. area 00:12:39.79\00:12:42.89 that are Jesuit institutions. 00:12:42.99\00:12:44.89 And they're designed not only to train priests, Jesuit priests, 00:12:45.46\00:12:49.00 but also non-Catholics can go there and get an education. 00:12:49.03\00:12:51.63 So it is one of their ways of educating people, 00:12:51.67\00:12:54.50 and at minimum introducing them to some of the elements 00:12:54.54\00:12:57.87 of the Catholic faith. 00:12:57.91\00:12:59.24 Then in later years those individuals may have 00:12:59.27\00:13:01.58 some kind of an experience that would lead them 00:13:01.61\00:13:03.51 into the Catholic faith. 00:13:03.55\00:13:04.88 That's a model that all Christian groups follow. 00:13:04.91\00:13:10.82 And indeed, all religions. 00:13:10.85\00:13:12.19 That's the reason to have an educational institution 00:13:12.22\00:13:16.19 and invite others in. 00:13:16.22\00:13:17.56 You want to influence them to your viewpoint. 00:13:17.63\00:13:19.43 ~ Sure. - It's not illegitimate at all. 00:13:19.46\00:13:21.80 In fact, I think it's been inordinately successful 00:13:21.83\00:13:24.77 in the United States. 00:13:24.80\00:13:26.17 I personally, as a matter of history, find a lot of the 00:13:27.04\00:13:29.34 anti-Catholicism of the United States 00:13:29.37\00:13:31.41 embarrassing, to say the least. 00:13:32.14\00:13:33.81 It was bigoted, and at times even violent. 00:13:33.84\00:13:37.21 So we can't defend that. 00:13:37.88\00:13:39.38 But when you're looking at 00:13:39.61\00:13:40.98 Protestantism verses Catholicism, 00:13:41.02\00:13:44.02 there's a great split with deep doctrinal reasons for it. 00:13:44.05\00:13:47.76 It's amazing that in this once Protestant society, 00:13:48.19\00:13:51.76 through many vehicles, but most particularly, I think, 00:13:52.59\00:13:55.20 these educational institutions run by the Jesuits, 00:13:55.23\00:13:57.57 they have been inordinately successful 00:13:57.60\00:14:00.27 in just churning out acolytes who in perhaps even 00:14:00.50\00:14:07.21 subtle ways are very sympathetic to the aims 00:14:07.24\00:14:10.08 of the Roman Catholic structure. 00:14:10.11\00:14:12.31 That would have been unimaginable 200 years ago. 00:14:12.35\00:14:15.18 ~ That is true. 00:14:15.65\00:14:16.99 In fact, it was back in roughly the 1820's through the 1860's 00:14:17.02\00:14:20.96 that there was a lot of debate in America regarding 00:14:21.19\00:14:23.59 public education. 00:14:23.63\00:14:24.96 Because at one time, being that this country was 00:14:24.99\00:14:28.46 predominately settled through Protestants, 00:14:28.50\00:14:31.20 the Bible was used in classrooms... 00:14:31.23\00:14:33.84 ~ Well, churches and communities ran the schools, 00:14:33.87\00:14:36.14 not the government. 00:14:36.17\00:14:37.51 ~ Yes, and from that influence, Protestantism... 00:14:37.54\00:14:41.54 The issue that became a church state issue in ensuing years 00:14:41.94\00:14:45.45 was that if you had Catholic pupils in those schools, 00:14:45.48\00:14:48.05 and they weren't simply going to acknowledge the Protestant Bible 00:14:48.15\00:14:52.19 or Protestant viewpoints, then that's where a lot of 00:14:52.22\00:14:54.76 controversy came about, so that eventually 00:14:54.79\00:14:56.83 by the 1880's with Dewey and his educational reform system, 00:14:57.19\00:15:01.60 he proposed the idea of making it a secular 00:15:01.90\00:15:04.40 educational environment. 00:15:04.43\00:15:05.87 Which by the next century in the 1900's the Supreme Court 00:15:05.97\00:15:09.94 hammered out specific decisions establishing that; 00:15:09.97\00:15:12.67 no prayer, no Bible reading in schools. 00:15:12.71\00:15:14.94 ~ The whole discussion of education... 00:15:14.98\00:15:16.68 You could end the prayer and Bible study; 00:15:17.11\00:15:19.51 that's a separation of church and state issue. 00:15:19.55\00:15:21.28 But the whole question of education is an interesting one. 00:15:21.32\00:15:24.49 As I say, religion was really the arbiter of education 00:15:24.79\00:15:30.86 for a long, long time, and then in the early society in 00:15:30.89\00:15:34.03 in the U.S. different communities would band together 00:15:34.06\00:15:36.43 and basically group fund. 00:15:36.46\00:15:38.63 But the idea of the state running education 00:15:39.20\00:15:41.50 is relatively new, and it coincides directly with the 00:15:41.54\00:15:44.07 industrialization of society and the need of the state to train 00:15:44.11\00:15:49.14 citizens for its own purposes. 00:15:49.74\00:15:51.48 That's basically what it boils down to. 00:15:51.51\00:15:53.11 And so we've then built a contradiction between 00:15:53.35\00:15:56.22 the original aims of education and goals 00:15:56.25\00:15:58.75 and the continuing goals of religionists. 00:15:58.79\00:16:01.19 Roman Catholics are only one of the groups. 00:16:01.29\00:16:02.89 Adventists run schools. 00:16:02.92\00:16:04.26 But there is a conflict between the state aims and those aims. 00:16:04.49\00:16:08.90 And they perhaps can co-exist. 00:16:09.10\00:16:11.67 But when you fund them together, you've built in 00:16:11.87\00:16:16.30 a conflict that I don't think is easily reconcilable. 00:16:16.34\00:16:19.11 And that's why, you know, going back to that debate, 00:16:19.54\00:16:22.71 kind of that time period in the 1820's through the 1860's, 00:16:22.74\00:16:25.51 one of the thrusts that the Catholics were putting forth, 00:16:25.81\00:16:29.15 they wanted to have their own schools to educate their 00:16:29.25\00:16:31.49 children as Catholics, but they wanted state support for that. 00:16:31.52\00:16:34.36 ~ Yes, and that's a big issue. 00:16:34.46\00:16:36.29 We'll take a short break. 00:16:36.32\00:16:37.66 We'll be back to continue this discussion of, 00:16:37.69\00:16:39.73 not just the Jesuits, but religious education, 00:16:40.20\00:16:42.46 and what are the deeper implications of that. 00:16:42.50\00:16:45.00 Stay with us. 00:16:45.03\00:16:46.43