Keepers of the Flame

After The Disappointment

Three Angels Broadcasting Network

Program transcript

Participants: Dr. Allan Lindsay (Host)

Home

Series Code: KOTF

Program Code: KOTF000004


00:59 - Seagulls cawing -
01:12 The Erie Canal was the first major waterway
01:14 built in the United States.
01:15 Opened in 1825, it crossed the state of New York
01:19 from Buffalo near Niagara Falls in the west
01:23 to Albany on the Hudson River in the east.
01:32 - Boat horn blowing -
01:38 About a half an hour's drive east of Rochester,
01:40 lies the small town of Port Gibson.
01:43 - Birds chirping - Located on the canal,
01:45 it was the once main shipping point for the area.
01:49 It was also the home of an active Methodist layman,
01:51 Hiram Edson, who in 1843, accepted the message
01:55 of the soon coming of Christ,
01:56 taught by William Miller and his associates.
02:01 With tens of thousands of others
02:03 across the United States, the Millerites at Port Gibson
02:06 waited with earnest expectation for October 22, 1844.
02:10 For on this day, they expected the Lord to come
02:13 as the fulfillment of the 2,300 day prophecy
02:17 of Daniel 8:14.
02:21 But as the clear morning light of the following day
02:23 shone upon the canal waters, these same believers
02:26 were overcome with disappointment and despair.
02:29 Just how they came to see beyond
02:31 their own misunderstanding to the clear light
02:34 of God's leading in three distinct ways
02:36 is the substance of our story.
02:52 There were many Adventist believers who gathered
02:54 at Hiram Edson's farm on October 22, 1844.
02:58 Research has established that this was his house
03:01 though rooms have been added on both sides
03:04 since the time Edson lived here.
03:09 On that cool October morning, the disappointment of Edson
03:13 and his friends became all too real.
03:15 That slips off the tongue mightily easily, young fella.
03:19 I beg your pardon, sir?
03:20 I don't think you have any idea how devastated we were.
03:25 What do you mean?
03:26 I'm telling you, we experienced the worst kind of doubt.
03:30 Some of us with more bitterness than others.
03:33 We wondered if the prophecies of Daniel were wrong?
03:37 We wondered if maybe the Bible was a fairy tale?
03:41 And some of us, even wondered
03:43 if there was still a God in Heaven?
03:46 We went to my barn back there, and we prayed,
03:51 and after re-examining our faith,
03:54 we decided that there had to be an answer to our dilemma.
03:59 And what was that?
04:00 Well, after we had eaten breakfast,
04:03 I suggested to young Owen Crosier that we visit
04:07 some of our neighbors in the area here,
04:09 and see if we could encourage them a bit.
04:11 I'm not sure if it was because of our fear
04:15 of our mocking neighbors, and anyway, we headed out
04:17 across my cornfield.
04:21 All that corn!
04:23 We'd been so sure of Christ's second coming,
04:26 that I'd left the whole crop standing in the field.
04:32 Have an ear of New York's finest?
04:34 Thank you. You're welcome.
04:35 You know, as we walked along that morning,
04:39 and I reviewed in my mind the events
04:41 of the previous 24 hours, suddenly, I stopped
04:45 and looked up into Heaven and it seems as if the heavens
04:49 opened and across my mind flashed the arrangement
04:52 of the Sanctuary.
04:53 You know, we Millerites, have been preaching the text,
04:57 Unto 2,300 days, then shall the sanctuary be cleansed.
05:01 And we thought that that sanctuary was this earth.
05:05 Well, later we realized that the Bible teaches that
05:10 there's a sanctuary in Heaven too,
05:13 and Christ had moved like the High Priest
05:17 on the Day of Atonement from the Holy Place
05:20 to the Most Holy Place on October 22, 1844.
05:25 Our Lord had a work to perform in Heaven
05:28 before returning to this earth.
05:31 That's where Brother Miller had made his mistake.
05:33 The Lord was good. He had heard our morning prayer.
05:39 Well, so long, young fella. So long.
05:57 In the following months, Hiram Edson and his associates
06:01 continued to study the subject of the sanctuary
06:03 and its cleansing.
06:05 As they thought of their own experience,
06:07 they marveled at the similarities
06:09 between their own disappointment
06:11 and that of the disciples
06:12 at the time of Jesus' crucifixion.
06:15 Eventually, Edson persuaded his friend, Crosier, to publish
06:19 their findings in an extra edition
06:21 of the Millerite journal, "The Daystar",
06:24 February 7, 1846.
06:26 - Birds singing -
06:30 - Dog barking -
06:40 But meanwhile, a second significant development
06:42 was taking place, here in Washington, New Hampshire.
06:46 Two years earlier, in 1844, a Seventh-day Baptist lady
06:50 had shared with a group of Millerite believers here
06:52 her conviction that the seventh day of the week
06:55 should be observed as the Sabbath.
06:56 - Organ playing -
07:04 The Christian observance of the seventh-day Sabbath
07:06 has persisted throughout the Christian era.
07:09 At times, it has been driven underground, but it has always
07:13 reappeared to urge its message upon the world.
07:19 From the days of the apostles, down to the 5th century,
07:22 it continued in various parts of the Roman empire.
07:25 However, as the Christian church slipped further and further
07:28 into apostasy, and adopted the idolatrous rites
07:32 and practices of sun worship,
07:33 the seventh-day Sabbath was soon discredited,
07:36 its observance suppressed and in its place,
07:39 Sunday was exalted as the day of worship.
07:46 During the Reformation of the 16th century,
07:48 Luther took his stand on the Bible
07:50 as the supreme authority for the Christian.
07:53 To Charles V, he declared,
07:56 "I do not accept the authority of Popes, and councils,
08:03 for they have contradicted each other.
08:06 My conscience is captive to the Word of God. "
08:11 This appeal to the Bible and the Bible only
08:14 was the very foundation of the Reformation.
08:26 As the Reformation continued, dialogue soon arose
08:29 within the church over the question
08:31 of Sunday and the Sabbath.
08:34 The Sabbath keepers asserted that there was no Bible support
08:37 for the observance of Sunday.
08:39 As a result, the observance of the seventh-day Sabbath
08:42 spread throughout Europe including England.
08:54 There, agitation over the Sabbath became
08:57 the center of controversy among the Puritans
08:59 throughout the 17th century.
09:01 - Bell tolling -
09:02 Influential people were involved.
09:04 Among the many who advocated
09:06 the observance of the seventh day
09:07 was a London barrister,
09:09 and a commonwealth speaker of the House of Commons.
09:17 - Congregation singing - By the mid-1660s,
09:20 there were many congregations in England
09:22 keeping the seventh day.
09:24 A member of one of them was Dr. Peter Chamberlen,
09:27 physician to three Stuart kings:
09:29 James I, Charles I and Charles II of England.
09:34 A contemporary of John Bunyan,
09:37 Chamberlen was a keen Bible student.
09:39 On his tombstone in the churchyard
09:42 at Woodham Mortimer, these words have being written:
09:46 As for his religion, he was a Christian
09:50 keeping the Commandments of God and faith of Jesus,
09:52 being baptized about the year 1648,
09:56 and keeping the seventh day for the Sabbath about 32 years.
10:03 Chamberlen was a member
10:04 of the Seventh-day Baptist Church -
10:05 a small group that had separated from the Baptist Church
10:08 in the early 1600s because of their convictions
10:12 concerning the Sabbath.
10:27 In 1664, Steven Mumford, a Seventh-day Baptist
10:31 from England, immigrated to the New World.
10:33 In 1671, he organized the first Seventh-day Baptist Church
10:38 in America at Newport, Rhode Island.
10:41 During the next 170 years, their influence spread
10:45 throughout America until, in 1843, Seventh-day Baptists
10:49 numbered about five and a half thousand.
10:52 In that year, their General Conference
10:54 voted on a most significant resolution.
10:57 That the first day of November next, be observed
11:01 by our churches as a day of fasting and prayer,
11:04 that Almighty God will arise and plead for His Holy Sabbath.
11:10 Little did they anticipate the manner or the magnitude
11:13 of the answer to their prayer.
11:18 Within months of their day of prayer,
11:20 a Seventh-day Baptist widow, Mrs. Rachel Oakes decided
11:24 to move to the little village of Washington, New Hampshire.
11:27 Her 18-year old daughter, Delight, had accepted
11:30 a position there as a school teacher.
11:36 Driving into Washington today, the marker on the roadside
11:40 states that this is the birthplace
11:42 of the Seventh-day Adventist Church.
11:45 What happened here to attract such a title?
11:55 This sturdy wooden church is today located
11:58 far from the town center, but once it was set
12:01 in the middle of the thriving farm community.
12:23 In 1844, Frederick Wheeler was the Methodist
12:26 circuit riding pastor of this church.
12:29 Two years earlier, after reading William Miller's books,
12:32 Wheeler began to teach the soon coming of Jesus.
12:35 The majority of his congregation here
12:38 also adopted Miller's teachings.
12:46 One Sunday morning, Wheeler was at this desk
12:49 in the Washington, New Hampshire church
12:51 conducting the communion service.
12:53 During the sermon, he encouraged the people
12:56 to be faithful in keeping all ten of God's Commandments.
12:59 Mrs. Oakes, the Seventh-day Baptist, who was attending
13:03 here for fellowship, could hardly contain herself.
13:09 When the pastor visited her soon after,
13:11 she seized her opportunity.
13:17 Reverend Wheeler! Hello, Rachel.
13:19 I'm glad to see you. Good to see you.
13:20 I've been looking forward to this.
13:21 I want to talk to you about something important.
13:23 What is the subject today?
13:25 Rachel: Come in.
13:31 Thank you, Mrs. Oakes. It's a lovely fire.
13:40 In Sunday's service, Reverend Wheeler,
13:44 you said that everyone who confesses Christ
13:47 should obey all God's commandments.
13:50 I am strongly of that opinion, sister.
13:54 Well, I'll be making it clear.
13:55 I came near standing up, right then and there
13:59 and saying something.
14:00 I sensed as such. What did you want to say?
14:03 I want to tell you that you had best put that cloth
14:07 back on the communion table, until you begin to keep
14:10 all God' Commandments yourself, including the fourth.
14:23 And so, Frederick Wheeler was introduced to the Sabbath truth.
14:26 Soon after, he kept his first Sabbath, preached a sermon on it
14:30 and, thus, became the first
14:32 Sabbath keeping Adventist minister.
14:38 Not long after The Great Disappointment,
14:40 William Farnsworth, then in his late 30s,
14:43 stood up in the Farnsworth family pew, during the service,
14:47 and declared his intention to keep the Sabbath also.
14:50 He was soon followed by his younger brother, Cyrus,
14:53 who was in his early 20s,
14:55 his own wife, and father and others.
15:00 Forced to withdraw from fellowship,
15:02 these first Sabbath keepers met in the large
15:05 Farnsworth Home, not far away.
15:08 It was not until some years later,
15:09 that they acquired eventual ownership of this church.
15:17 Adjacent to the church is the graveyard, where many
15:20 of these early Seventh-day Sabbath keepers lie buried.
15:29 This marker reveals that Cyrus Farnsworth,
15:32 later married Rachel Delight Oakes,
15:35 the schoolteacher and daughter of Mrs. Rachel Oakes.
15:41 A short time after Wheeler commenced to keep the Sabbath,
15:43 a second Millerite minister, Thomas Preble, joined him.
15:49 Preble was a Free Will Baptist who had traveled
15:52 with William Miller,
15:53 and proclaimed the soon coming of Jesus.
15:55 He became the first Sabbath keeping Adventist
15:57 to advocate the seventh-day Sabbath in printed form
16:01 in an article he published in February 1845.
16:06 Among the many who read his article, which was later
16:09 printed as a tract, was Joseph Bates,
16:12 a retired sea captain.
16:14 He was impressed with its truth.
16:16 Some years before, Bates had accepted
16:19 the teachings of William Miller.
16:20 He held key positions in the Millerite movement
16:23 and managed to weather the storm of the disappointment
16:26 of 1844, without losing his faith.
16:52 Hearing of the company of Sabbath keepers
16:54 in Washington, he journeyed there,
16:56 but, on the way, he met with Frederick Wheeler
16:58 on his Hillsboro Farm.
17:01 - Knocking on door -
17:08 They studied the Bible together throughout the night.
17:18 Next morning, they both went to Washington
17:21 to Cyrus Farnsworth's home.
17:46 Here at the Farnsworth home in 1845,
17:49 after further study with Wheeler and Farnsworth,
17:52 Bates made his decision about the Sabbath.
18:10 Returning home, Bates was crossing the bridge
18:13 between Fairhaven and New Bedford, Massachusetts.
18:16 Only the approaches to the bridge remain today.
18:20 On the bridge, Bates met an old friend,
18:23 James Madison Monroe Hall, who asked him a question.
18:27 What's the news, Captain Bates?
18:29 The news is that the seventh-day
18:31 is the Sabbath of the Lord our God.
18:37 And Bates devoted the remainder of his life
18:40 to proclaiming that news.
18:44 In August of 1846, Bates published his own tracts,
18:47 "The Seventh-day Sabbath: A Perpetual Sign. "
18:50 Its contents pointed to a spiritual heritage
18:53 received not only from the Seventh-day Baptists,
18:55 but also from the English Puritans and others before them.
18:59 It contained, as well, an important new idea
19:02 that heralded the prophetic significance
19:05 of the developing Seventh-day Adventist Church.
19:09 - Seagulls cawing -
19:13 After Bates had began to keep the Sabbath,
19:15 he noticed something that the Millerites had overlooked.
19:18 They had seen their movement as the fulfillment
19:21 of the First and Second Angels' messages of Revelation 14,
19:24 which were to be proclaimed
19:26 prior to the Second Coming of Jesus.
19:28 But there was also a Third Angel's message.
19:31 Bates noted that Revelation 14:12 describes
19:37 the people, who are preaching these messages, as those
19:40 who keep the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus.
19:45 This confirmed in his mind the importance
19:47 of keeping the commandments.
19:50 It seemed to him that the time had come
19:52 for a people who had proclaimed the First and Second Angels'
19:55 messages, to recognize the third message
19:58 and to keep the commandments of God
20:00 and the Sabbath the fourth command enjoined.
20:05 Earlier in 1846, Bates received a copy of "The Daystar Extra,"
20:09 which explained Hiram Edson's insights
20:11 into the Heavenly Sanctuary
20:13 and Christ's ministry in the Most Holy Place.
20:17 He began to correspond with Edson
20:19 and accepted his invitation to a conference
20:22 to be held in Port Gibson later that year.
20:25 There, Edson shared his insights into the sanctuary.
20:28 But Bates, too, had something to share.
20:33 As Bates outlined his reasons
20:35 for keeping the seventh-day Sabbath,
20:37 Edson jumped to his feet and declared,
20:39 "That is light and truth.
20:41 The seventh-day is the Sabbath
20:43 and I am with you to keep it. "
20:46 And keep it, he did till the day of his death.
20:58 But, in his conversation with the Port Gibson leaders,
21:00 Bates also began to see a connection
21:02 between the Sabbath and Christ's ministry
21:05 in the Most Holy Place of the Heavenly Sanctuary.
21:12 - Sounds of Christ writhing in pain -
21:19 Jesus was at the center of both teachings.
21:23 In one, He was the all sufficient sacrifice
21:26 as God's Lamb, as well as High Priest
21:29 ministering the blood and cleansing the sanctuary.
21:31 - Thunderclap -
21:32 In the other, He was the creator of the world,
21:35 and giver of true rest.
21:38 The 1846 conference was the first public expression
21:42 of such a connection.
21:50 At this conference, Bates listened with great interest
21:53 to Edson's ideas about the Heavenly Sanctuary.
21:58 He knew the Bible taught that the Ark of the Covenant
22:00 was located in the sanctuary's second apartment
22:03 and that inside the ark were the Ten Commandments.
22:06 With great interest therefore, he read Revelation 11:18
22:10 which speaks of the final days of earth's history,
22:13 when the nations would be angry and the time had come
22:16 for the world's last judgment.
22:18 But, then, in the next verse he read,
22:21 that at the same time, the Temple of God
22:23 or the Heavenly Sanctuary, was to be opened
22:25 and there was seen in His temple
22:28 the Ark of His Testament.
22:33 Bates reasoned that if Jesus' ministry in the Most Holy Place
22:36 was now the focus of attention,
22:38 then the ark, its law, and the seventh-day Sabbath
22:42 that law commanded also assumed new importance.
22:46 The fulfillment of the 2,300 year prophecy
22:48 in 1844, had therefore drawn attention
22:51 to the Heavenly Sanctuary in a way never seen before.
22:55 As a result, two special emphases
22:58 concerning Jesus emerged.
23:02 First, He was now engaged in His final work
23:05 as our High Priest in the Most Holy Ministry
23:07 of that sanctuary.
23:08 Second, He was Lord of the Sabbath day,
23:12 and had both commanded the seventh-day to be kept Holy
23:15 and observed it Himself as our divine example.
23:20 But there was to be a third distinguishing sign
23:23 associated with God's great final proclamation
23:26 of the gospel.
23:27 It too was to come from Jesus, for in Revelation 12:17
23:31 it is identified as the testimony of Jesus.
23:34 Just what does this mean?
23:41 In Revelation 12, John describes the woman
23:44 clothed with the Sun, representing the church.
23:47 - Woman screaming in labor pain -
23:48 He sees her waiting for the birth of Jesus
23:50 then persecuted and lead away into the wilderness
23:53 where God protects her for a period of 1,260 years.
23:58 Verse 17 then says, The dragon was enraged
24:02 at the woman and went off to make war against
24:05 the rest of her offspring, who obey God's Commandments
24:08 and hold to the testimony of Jesus.
24:14 A comparison between Revelation 19:10 and 22:8
24:18 reveals that the testimony of Jesus,
24:20 declared to be the Spirit of Prophecy,
24:23 operates through the prophets.
24:25 Those individuals He has chosen
24:27 to speak His testimony to His people.
24:30 The Old Testament prophet, Joel records...
24:33 And afterward, I will pour out My Spirit on all people;
24:37 Your sons and daughters will prophesy,
24:40 Your old men will dream dreams,
24:43 Your young men will see visions.
24:45 Even on my servants, both men and women,
24:48 I will pour out My Spirit in those days.
24:53 The context of these verses points to their ultimate
24:56 fulfillment in the days before the coming
24:58 of the great and dreadful day of the Lord.
25:02 The 19th century revealed several impressive fulfillments
25:05 of this prediction.
25:18 In the late 1830s, a young American black, who was
25:22 converted at the age of 17,
25:24 moved here to Boston, Massachusetts
25:26 to prepare for the gospel ministry.
25:29 His name was William Foy.
25:34 During 1842, Foy received two impressive visions.
25:39 He later published a description
25:41 in a pamphlet entitled
25:42 "The Christian Experience of William E. Foy
25:45 Together with the Two Visions He Received
25:48 in the Months of January and February 1842."
26:01 On Tuesday evening, January 18, 1842,
26:04 23-year old Foy was meeting with a group of Christians
26:07 for prayer and Bible study, here in Beacon Hill, Boston.
26:11 During the meeting,
26:12 he experienced the first of four visions.
26:15 It lasted for two and a half hours,
26:17 during which a Doctor Cummings examined him,
26:20 and could find - and I quote -
26:22 "No appearance of life, except around the heart. "
26:26 - Preacher preaching - In his vision, Foy witnessed
26:28 the rewards given to the righteous
26:30 at the Second Coming
26:31 and was shown the matchless beauty of Heaven.
26:34 He was hesitant to share his visions, for he knew
26:37 the prejudice against blacks.
26:39 But less than three weeks later,
26:41 he was given another vision
26:42 while meeting in a crowded church.
26:44 This vision, lasting twelve and a half hours,
26:48 revealed the scenes of the great judgment day.
26:50 ...it is with deep regret that I must now
26:53 pass judgment upon your life.
26:55 As a child, you were fortunate to have the benefit
26:58 of God-fearing and loving parents.
27:00 As the scenes passed before him,
27:02 he saw that neither profession, politics, nor status can save -
27:07 only a relationship with Christ.
27:10 In fact, if notice had been taken of his vision
27:13 concerning the pre-Advent judgment,
27:15 perhaps the Great Disappointment two years later,
27:18 may have been softened, if not avoided all together.
27:28 Foy was told to relate to others what he had seen.
27:31 And during the months that followed,
27:33 he preached extensively, creating a sensation
27:36 wherever he went.
27:37 Vast crowds heard him tell of what he had seen
27:41 of the Heavenly world, and the need to prepare for it.
27:45 It appears that two more visions were given to him
27:48 including one revealing three steps to the Heavenly City
27:52 which he did not understand.
27:54 For nation shall rise against nation,
27:56 and kingdom against kingdom,
27:58 and there shall be famines, pestilences...
28:01 No more visions were given to William Foy
28:03 after the disappointment.
28:05 However, he maintained his hope
28:07 in the Second Coming of Christ.
28:09 He continued as an esteemed and beloved preacher
28:12 in small rural communities,
28:14 finally settling in East Sullivan, Maine.
28:17 And this gospel of the kingdom
28:19 shall be preached into all the world
28:21 for a witness unto all nations...
28:24 There he died in November 1893
28:27 and was buried here in the Birch Tree Cemetery.
28:44 Shortly before the Great Disappointment,
28:46 God placed a prophetic gift on another - Hazen Foss -
28:51 who lived in Poland, Maine.
28:54 He was 25 years old, well educated, a good speaker
28:58 and a believer in the soon coming of Jesus.
29:02 In his first vision, he was shown the journey
29:05 of the Advent people to the City of God.
29:07 It corroborated with Foy's visions and included a view
29:11 of three steps
29:12 by which God's people approach the Holy City.
29:15 After the disappointment, he was told to relate
29:18 what he had seen.
29:20 Fearing opposition, Foss refused.
29:25 In a second vision, he was again urged to share
29:27 what he had seen.
29:29 But still, he refused.
29:31 A third vision followed in which he was told
29:34 that he was released and that the burden
29:37 would be laid upon one of the weakest of the weak
29:39 who would do the Lord's bidding.
29:41 - Church bell tolling -
29:51 A few weeks later, Foss stood outside the door
29:54 of a little chapel, listening to a miraculous story.
29:58 He was urged to come into the meeting,
30:00 but he refused.
30:02 ...the manna, almonds, figs, pomegranates and grapes,
30:07 and the other fruits.
30:09 I asked Jesus to let me eat of them.
30:11 He said, "Not now. "
30:13 Those that eat of this fruit
30:15 return to earth no more.
30:18 You must go back and relate to others
30:21 what I have revealed to you.
30:24 Then the angel bore me gently down...
30:27 What he heard was an account of the vision
30:29 almost identical to the one given him.
30:35 Who was it that Foss saw that night?
30:39 Her name was Ellen Harmon, a 17 year old girl
30:43 so ravaged by tuberculosis, it threatened to take her life.
30:47 She could barely speak in a whisper and was often
30:50 wakened from sleep by coughing and bleeding in her lungs.
30:54 Yet God took this weakest of the weak,
30:57 and called her to give the testimony of Jesus
31:00 to His people.
31:01 And powered by God's Spirit, she was to bear that testimony
31:04 for the next 70 years.
31:11 The explanation of the sanctuary,
31:12 the seventh-day Sabbath truth,
31:15 and a modern manifestation of the Spirit of Prophecy -
31:17 These three key revelations helped lead many
31:21 through the disappointment of 1844.
31:24 And it was the last of these in the person
31:26 of Mrs. Ellen Gould White, who was to continue to act
31:29 as a compass for this fledgling group of believers
31:32 well into the 20th century.
31:33 It is to her story we turn next.
31:42 Captioning made possible by 3ABN viewers
31:44 and supporters.


Home

Revised 2014-12-17